Want this too?

287 people want software patents abolished.

In the software world, patents are stifling innovation instead of encouraging it!

Companies are patenting small, simple ideas that then get used unknowingly in other software and then suing them for using those obvious ideas. (Lodsys, who is suing any phone app developer who uses in-app transactions, is the latest example of this.)

The traditional argument for patents is that they encourage innovation by granting inventors a twenty-year monopoly on their inventions. First of all, twenty years in the software world is WAY too long. Even the best ideas don't deserve to be locked up that long.

But more importantly, software patents are unnecessary. Innovation in software is rewarding enough without the added benefit of a patent monopoly.
Askers (287)












Keywords: patent, patents, software
Categories: Inventions, Technology, Internet & Websites
Started: 01 Jun 2011  
Discussion (19)
Once you're logged in, you can post new comments and reply.
Rocks, 27-Sep-16
Excellent goods from you, man. http://www.sbgamehackerapk.net/
I've be aware your stuff previous to and you are just too great.
I actually like what you have acquired right here, certainly like what you are stating and the best way during which you assert it. You make it entertaining and you continue to care for to keep it sensible. http://fileextensionapk.org/ I cant wait to read far more from you. That is really a wonderful website. http://www.gamehackerapk.net/ http://gamekillerapkdownload.net/ http://www.nba2k16apk.net/

0 Replies     
Chirag, 14-Sep-16
New Year Packages 2017 near Delhi NCR. New Year 2017 is an

occasion of delights. So let's celebrate it together with

enjoyable and a wonderful seasoning
0 Replies     
sahiul akhtar, 09-Aug-16
Nainital Travel Guide - Planning to take a Nainital Tour? Check out Goibibo to know more about Nainital tourism, Nainital tourist places, and best tour packages.

0 Replies     
Casey, 15-Aug-12
I agree. And for patenting other things. The whole system seems to be only there for larger corporations to suppress start ups from coming up with ideas. The bottom line is who can afford the patent and legal fees, and can afford to document everything.

It seems like patenting is a waste of time, because if you patent something, someone else can modify it, then make an improvement patent, which you are forced to allow in order to improve your idea. So it seems like you should be able to make anything as long as it's not an exact replica (copyright) of something else.
0 Replies     
McKane, 21-Oct-11
Talking about how software patent trolls may ruin silicon valley.
0 Replies     
McKane, 04-Oct-11
A great article about the absurdity of software patents and the history of how we got where we are now... http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_... Definately worth a read.
0 Replies     
Matthew, 18-Jun-11
This all started with Amazon's One Click patent, which makes it nearly impossible for any other company (besides those it licenses such as Apple Store) to enable site visitors to purchase with a single click of the mouse. I just can't see how reacting to behavior of customers can be interpreted as a patentable action.
0 Replies     
Amin, 02-Jun-11
You can't put a patent on mathematical expressions. It's nonsense.
0 Replies     
Guillermo, 01-Jun-11
yay we less than 200 people agree on it, i'm almost sure its going to be done with this kind of support
2 Replies     
Duane, 01-Jun-11
Also relevant (and mentioned in the comments of "Enough is Enough"):
0 Replies     
Angel, 01-Jun-11
0 Replies     
Daniel, 01-Jun-11
As I've argued on my blog (
) the whole patent system is a bit of a mess - and that's even without throwing in the utter disaster of software patents.

We're lucky not to have software patents in the UK. It really sucks that the US, which otherwise leads the world in entrepreneurship and tech startups, has software patents.
0 Replies     
Mark, 01-Jun-11
Dino, yes there are many software patents that need to be protected, but then there are reaaaally obvious patents that need to be abolished. I believe most of the obvious ones include internet technology patents as well as mobile technology patents.
0 Replies     
Dino, 01-Jun-11
This is ridiculous. All software patents are not obvious. There are some remarkably meritorious software patents in crystalography and genetics. This is a terribly misinformed movement that uses a broad brush mob mentality. And askforit is stupid for making me ask for it before commenting. I leaves no room for dissent.
2 Replies     
McKane, 01-Jun-11
As someone who has dealt with these in my occupation, I agree with this strongly. The poster child for this is the Amazon 1-click checkout, but there are lots of other examples.
0 Replies     
Edit | Delete |
Progress (4)
Once you're logged in, you can view and post progress.

We need to link this Ask to a real person. This can be done in one of 3 ways:

  • Log into your existing account (Facebook or Non-Facebook), or...
  • Create a new account, or...
  • Use your name and email and confirmed through an email.

Facebook Sign in
Login with Facebook
- OR -
Non-Facebook Account Sign-in

- OR -

Ask For It Now!  –  No Account Required
Real Name:
Re-type Email

* = Required. Note: You will receive a single confirmation email.

Do you want to delete this Request?

Do you want to withdraw from this Ask?